The idea of tuition free college has gained popularity among some politicians and state leaders over the past few years. The rising tuition and debt of graduates has been a driving force in these discussions. Minnesota Office of Higher Education staff prepared a brief discussing free college pros, cons, and alternatives Minnesota could adopt to lower tuition costs for students and families. The brief is summarized below.
“Free college” programs are generally last dollar scholarship programs that cover tuition for undergraduates after all other grants or scholarships have been applied. Examples of “free college” programs include the Tennessee Promise, the Hawaii College Promise, and the New York Excelsior Scholarship. Although aspects of each “free college” program may vary, plans typically include some combination of the following program components:
Although program language suggests that college is “free” for undergraduates, often these programs cover less than half of the costs to students and their families. “Free college” programs cover tuition, but may not cover fees, and typically do not cover other non-tuition costs such as books, transportation, and living expenses.
Total ‘Free College’ Funds by Family, Eligibility Limited to Families with Income <$125,000 and Students Attending Public Institutions
The Office of Higher Education analyzed data on tuition and fees, Pell Grants, and Minnesota State Grants for Minnesota resident undergraduates enrolled at a public institution who applied for aid in the 2017-2018 academic year and projected results forward to the 2019-2020 academic year.
Yes, for the lowest income studentsOf the 137,000 undergraduates enrolled at Minnesota public institutions, approximately 38,000 students (28%) received combined federal Pell Grant and Minnesota State Grant aid that was equal to or greater than the average tuition and fees charged.
Minnesota Dependent Students Percent Receiving Pell + State Grants Covering 100 Percent of Tuition & Fees by Income, FY 2020 Estimates
The cost of any “free college” program depends on the overall design of the program. Overall, the fewer students eligible, the lower the cost of the program. Programs that have less restrictive eligibility requirements and/or cover a wider range of college costs tend to be more expensive.
For the purposes of this analysis, three versions of “free college” programs with different eligibility requirements were chosen to illustrate the costs of a potential “free college” program in Minnesota. The three examples range from highly restricted eligibility and application processes to more broadly defined/accessible programs. The programs modeled here capture the primary aspects of the original program, while incorporating elements that would allow the program to better fit the higher education needs of Minnesotans. The three examples chosen for this analysis are: Hawai’i Promise (less restrictive), New York’s Excelsior Scholarship (moderately restrictive), and Tennessee Promise (more restrictive).
Read more about examples of “free college” program options, costs, and other information about financial aid in the full brief.